Making Memories At Morton House In Shipshewana, IN. One Of The Great Places To Stay In Indiana.

Such a beautiful, cozy space!

Our stay at Morton House Inn was like being welcomed into a dear friend’s home, wrapped in the heart of Shipshewana’s Amish charm. Von and Tobi, the owners, have poured their heart and souls into this historic 1880s gem, and it shows in every detail. From the moment we arrived, their warmth set the tone— the cozy farmhouse decor, made the place feel both timeless and inviting. The smell of the home is incredible!

We were greeted by the most inviting entrance

Three of the rooms are upstairs.

This would be a great place to relax and read a book.

This captures the feel of the outdoor and indoor spaces all in one photo.

The entryway was equipped with the items you need to go down the street and play pickleball.

The suite was a dream—spotless, with a plush queen bed, soft linens, and a rainfall shower that melted the day’s travel away. Donuts and coffee that kept flowing, all in a sunlit dining room that begged us to linger.

The Hostetler Suite was the perfect setup....

with a place to sit and plan our day,

a full length mirror to check ourselves,

and a spacious bathroom with double sinks and a rainfall shower.

It's double occupancy if that's what you need.

An early morning view of the horse drawn buggies.

Being steps from downtown’s shops and the flea market made exploring effortless, but it was the quiet moments—like hearing horse-drawn buggies pass by as you wake or sipping coffee on the porch—that stole our hearts.

Von and Tobi’s love for Shipshewana shines through, from their quick text check-ins to the way they’ve honored the inn’s history while updating it with care. This wasn’t just a stay; it was a memory we'll carry forever. If you’re seeking a place that feels like home in the heart of Amish country, book with them—you’ll leave feeling like family.